‘Alf’s Gone’- The Boy who fell off Tattershall Castle
A few years ago, whilst researching something unconnected. I spotted a reference to, “a declaration of Mr Alfred Elmitt and others as to a fall from the top wall of Tattershall Castle.” Unfortunately I could discover no more than this teasing reference at the time. However, my interest was sparked and trawling the internet I discovered a document in the Devon County Archives. It is dated -28th June 1909- and has the name ‘Clitherow and Son, Tattershall’ written in a neat, copperplate style at the foot of the page. Only the image of the document’s cover is accessible online although there is an indication that the declaration extends to over seven pages. Further enquiries suggest that another copy may reside in the Lincoln Archives.
Being raised within site of the castle (albeit over the river in Coningsby) I was curious to learn more about Master Alfred Elmitt’s claim to fame. There was nothing to be gleaned from the National Trust either online or making enquiries using the property website. However, I managed to trace Alfred through the census returns from 1871 through to the 1911 census. These suggested Alfred was born on 21st September 1870 at Tattershall Thorpe (to Charles Elmitt and Mary (Mastin) of Lawn House, Coningsby). Although it appears Alfred married Emily Creasey (1900) and died in 1934 very little is revealedregarding his early life or his adventures at Tattershall. However, I did find someone has uploaded an Elmitt family tree onto a genealogy site with references to not only the declaration statement but also to newspaper cuttings from the 1930s which reveal a few of the details surrounding Alfred’s accident.
Published in 1933 under the heading ‘And Lived to tell the Tale’ articles in the Lincolnshire Standard and Boston Guardian revisit the eventful occasion in 1879 when Alfred Elmitt left his home (2 Princess St, Boston) on Whit Monday (June 2nd) to visit the castle. He journeyed with his three brothers; Henry, George and Joseph because Henry had been commissioned to make some drawings of Tattershall Castle for his employers, Messrs. Bellamy and Hardy of Lincoln. The group of lads managed to climb to the top of the castle keep and it was whilst stepping across the south-east corner of the battlement terrace that Alfred believed he either “slipped or turned dizzy and fell to the bottom” a distance of 76ft down the inside of the keep. This might sound confusing to those who know the castle today but one should remember that allthis was all prior to the castle being renovated by Lord Curzon (and subsequently the National Trust) when it must have been in a pretty ruinous state. Indeed the castle is described in one of the articles as having ‘no floors or roofs.’ George Elmitt told reporters that he heard his older brother Henry exclaim, “Alf’s gone” and remembered “hearing a thud at the end of his brother’s fall.” Nine year-old Alfred was taken straight to his home at Lodge Farm (Tattershall) where he was attended by a Dr Blades. Some believe Alfred must have been severely disabled by the fall but the cuttings suggest that luck was on his side and he suffered no more than a pronounced limp.
That would have been the end of the tale were it not for local historian, Phillip Skipworth who spent a good deal of his free-time showing visitors around the castle in the early years of the 20th century. Again this was prior to the efforts of Lord Curzon in 1910 to see the castle saved from decay and pillaging and long before it was restored and handed over to the National Trust (1925). Apparently few visitors would believe Mr Skipworth when he told them a boy had fallen off the keep and survived. Mr Skipworth recalls being told to ‘tell it to the Marines’ and got so tired of being disbelieved that in 1909 he had the affidavit drawn up by Clitherows (Horncastle solicitors) and signed by many of those connected or witness to the incident. One of the deponents was Mary Jane Unthank, of Castle House, Tattershall, who had been the caretaker and keyholder at the castle for nearly 40 years. Another, Alfred’s brother George, by this time the Rev. George Elmitt of Stockton Manitoba (Canada), was contacted so his signature could be added; perhaps in the hope that none would dare question the word of a cleric. Even Alfred’s schoolmaster, Mr Richard Seed, recalled an entry he made in the school log-book for June 5th 1879 which read, “Alfred Elmitt, a boy of about nine, absent from school through a fall from Tattershall Castle, a distance of upwards of seventy feet.”
Sadly Alfred died at what we may regard as the relatively early age of 64 on November 22nd 1934 it seems only a few newspaper cuttings survive to bear testimony to his fifteen minutes of fame and amazing escape from death.
Mark Temple
10th March 2019